Text 23516, 58 rader
Skriven 2006-01-24 19:38:12 av Paul Sanders (3:633/104)
  Kommentar till text 23463 av Roy Witt (1:1/22)
Ärende: Editor's censorship
===========================
 PS>>>>>>>> Not pre-emptive strikes, thats for sure.
 PS>> (paul says attacks on israel were *not* pre-emptive)

RW>Which means that the Israeli' initiated and attacked those with whom they
RW>had wars with in the last 58 years.

Roy, we were refering to attack *on* Israel, not attack by Israel.

 RW>>>>>>> So, they were friendly invites for tea and crumpets then?
 PS>> (roy disputes what paul has said)

RW>One does not dispute by asking questions.
in the case of your 'question' it was.

 PS>>>>>> No evidence to suggest that Israel was going to attack those
 PS>>>>>> countries.

 PS>> (paul says no evidence to say that israel was going to attack those
 PS>> countries)

RW>But they were attacked by their Arab neighbors without warning; which
RW>is a preemptive action.

No, it is not.
Those attacks against Israel would have been pre-emptive if is was
believed that Israel was about to attack them.

 RW>>>>> So you're a mind reader now...
 PS>> (basically roy disputes this)

RW>If there was no evidence, as you claim, you must have the ability to read
RW>their minds...

There is no evidence that Israel was going to attack.
The attacks against Israel were not pre-emptive.

 PS>>>> Oh, do you have evidence that suggests Isreal was going to attack
 PS>>>> those countries ?

 RW>>> It seems that you don't. Thanks for making my point.

 PS>> (roy now agree with paul)

RW>Roy doesn't agree with Paul...because Israel didn't preemptively attack
RW>anyone.
(roy has no idea what the discussion was about)

You completely missed the direction of the discussion, it was about
Israel being attacked, not Israel attacking.


 cya later,

 Paul

... Everyone is entitled to my opinion.
--- Ezycom V2.01b006 00F90257
 * Origin: Afraid of the competition? We ARE the Competition! (3:633/104)