Text 40871, 95 rader
Skriven 2006-10-06 09:24:37 av Jeff Smith (1:14/0)
  Kommentar till text 40832 av Matt Bedynek (1:106/1)
Ärende: DUD-file
================
Hello Matt.

06 Oct 06 01:55, you wrote to me:

 MB> Hello Jeff.

 MB> 04 Oct 06 13:59, you wrote to me:

 MB>>> ,1,copyright(c)_matt_bedynek,Houston_TX,all_rights_reserved,00..
 MB>>> .


 JS>>      As an RC I would inquire as to the intent of such a
 JS>> suggested listing. I would be disposed to deny such a listing
 JS>> unless it could be satisfactorally demonstrated why is was
 JS>> nessesary. Let me say though that I wouldn't expect that to
 JS>> happen.

 MB> Though such a listing requires one to mangle the fields a little, I
 MB> would allow any listing as long as it contains the minimum required
 MB> info.  Location and sysop name.  So, in my case, such a listing would
 MB> not be allowed, not because of personal reasons, but a technical one.


     I guess I would tend to be a tad more particular. I agree with you on
technical reasons.


 JS>>      While I understand the wish to imploy a copyright. I think
 JS>> that the unesessary use or the use simply to play some game which
 JS>> I think is the real case here only serves to cause needless
 JS>> problems.

 MB> Considering the attitude the Michiel and bjorn have about copyrights I
 MB> do not believe it was meant to be taken seriously or even can be taken
 MB> seriously.  As much as we want, we must learn to look at things with
 MB> more open eyes and try to understand the why rather than viewing
 MB> everything through an American prespective.


     That is why I have tried to discuss the matter with both Michiel
and Björn. To better understand their intent and maybe their reasons
for this use of copyrights in Fidonews. As I understand it based on what
Michiel has stated. His intent was to limit the distribution of Fidonews
containg his articles to prevent the distribution of said articles to
locations such as websites and BBS's. Specifically including Shannon's
website/bbs. To me this use of copyrights is based on a personal dislike
for one or more individuals. And an attempt to filter out certain people
from being able to distribute or display Michiel's articles.


 MB>  I believe what michiel
 MB> did was not meant to be a joke or jab at the rigid American way of
 MB> thinking as they precieve it in this echo.  And, you have do admit,
 MB> there are some people here with some very rigid views who refuse to
 MB> see anything from the prespective of others.

     That would describe the attitude that I get from Michiel quite
well. I have tried several times and several differant ways to reason
with Michiel. He insist's that the current Z2 way of doing things is
right even though it isn't working. He refuses to even consider that
there may be a better way. And also considers any ideas or suggestions
that come from other zones as suspect and not to be trusted.


 MB>  I do not see that as
 MB> being an attack on American society at all either but, more or less,
 MB> his way of trying to make a point.  But instead of trying to
 MB> understand why he did what he did some decide to capitalize on the
 MB> situation and attack someone they find disagreable.  Contrary to
 MB> popular belief and what we want to belief, people can be vendictive
 MB> like that.


     While maybe not a specific attack on America. It it Michiels way
of showing his dislike and distrust of things American IMHO. He has
shown this attitude in both his actions regarding copyrights as well
as his discussion and responses here on the subject. I have my doubts
that we would be having this discussion if Shannon and his BBS were
based in zone 2.



 MB> Matt

 MB> em: matt [at] thunderdome.us | icq: 16568532 | yahoo: mbedynek

 MB> ---
 MB>  * Origin: ..::[ high speed feeds - http://fido.thunderdome.us/ ]::..
 MB> (1:106/1)

Jeff

--- FMail/Win32 1.60
 * Origin: Twin_Cities_Metronet - MN USA (1:14/0)