Text 360, 79 rader
Skriven 2006-04-21 11:01:09 av Vladimir Donskoy (2:5020/2992)
    Kommentar till text 340 av Michiel van der Vlist (2:280/5555)
Ärende: Re: Situation on R2:50
==============================
Hi Michiel!

Thursday April 20 2006, Michiel van der Vlist wrote to Vladimir Donskoy:

 MV>>> And what was|were the question(s) in the referendum?

 VD>> Questions:
 VD>> _A_
 VD>> Are you agree with idea that it's time to increase the role of R2:50
 VD>> in world Fidonet due to the fact that it forms the majority of the
 VD>> world Fidonet?

 VD>> Choices of answers:

 MV> Oh boy, ... you really have NO idea how to properly conduct a referendum
 MV> do you? A referendum should always have a simple unambiguous question with
 MV> just a yes/no answer.

I have explained earlier, that to us it was important not only to receive the
answer yes/is not present, but also to find out a concrete variant of structure
of a new zone.

 MV> Multiple answers are a sure way to failure as I will demonstrate.

 VD>> _A1_
 VD>> I am agree we have to form Z7 for migration of all R50's sysops into
 VD>> it. Comment: with keeping numbers of networks.

 VD>> The results of referenda:
 VD>> Total amount of votes -- 561.
 VD>>  Choice €1 -- 140

 MV> So only 140 out of 561 = 25%  voted in favour of this option -> Rejected.

 VD>> _A2_
 VD>>  I am agree that Z7 should be formed of volunteers first for purpose
 VD>> of clearing technical and political questions of the migration. Total
 VD>> migration (as in variant "A1") is expected in some time later.
 VD>> Comment: with new address maps.

 VD>>  Choice €2 --  68

 MV> So only 68 out of 561 = 12% voted in favour of this option. -> Rejected.


 VD>> _A3_
 VD>> I am agree with both of "A1" and "A2".

 VD>>  Choice €3 -- 146

 MV> So only 146 out of 561 = 26% voted in favour of this option -> Rejected.

All the above-stated variants mean the consent with creation of a zone and as
to choose for the answer it was possible only one - voices with similar
subjects are summarized.

So A1+A2+A3 = 354 votes and "yes" for creation zone.

 VD>> _A4_
 VD>> I am not agree with all above.

 VD>>  Choice €4 --  34

 MV> So only 34 out of 561 = 6% voted in favour of this option -> Rejecetd.

 MV> Need I go on?

 MV> It appears that all the options were rejected.

No.

 MV> Sorry mate, you blew it.

You have not understood a principle of this referendum.

Regards, Vladimir Donskoy

--- GoldED+/W32-MINGW 1.1.5-b20060218
 * Origin: DVB Station (2:5020/2992)